The Complete Non-Bible Story Collection is a follow-up to The Complete Bible Story Collection, as it features stories that are not based on Bible stories.
Stories
- Tales from the Crisper (from Where's God When I'm S-Scared?)
- The Grapes of Wrath (from God Wants Me to Forgive Them!?!)
- Larry's Lagoon (from God Wants Me to Forgive Them!?!)
- The Gourds Must Be Crazy (from Are You My Neighbor?)
- The Toy That Saved Christmas
- Larry-Boy! and the Fib from Outer Space!
- Madame Blueberry
- Larry-Boy and the Rumor Weed
- Omelet (from Lyle the Kindly Viking)
- Lyle the Kindly Viking
- The Star of Christmas
- An Easter Carol
- Dr. Jiggle and Mr. Sly (from A Snoodle's Tale)
- A Snoodle's Tale
- Going Up (from Sumo of the Opera)
- The Story of St. Patrick (from Sumo of the Opera)
- Sumo of the Opera
- Bully Trouble (from Minnesota Cuke and the Search for Samson's Hairbrush)
- Minnesota Cuke and the Search for Samson's Hairbrush
- Lord of the Beans
- The Asparagus of LaMancha (from Sheerluck Holmes and the Golden Ruler)
- Sheerluck Holmes and the Golden Ruler
- LarryBoy and the Bad Apple
- The Story of George Mueller (from Gideon: Tuba Warrior)
- Bob's Vacation (from God Made You Special)
- The Pirates Who Don't Do Anything: A VeggieTales Movie
- Tomato Sawyer and Huckleberry Larry's Big River Rescue
- Blunders in Boo-Boo Ville (from Abe and the Amazing Promise)
- Minnesota Cuke and the Search for Noah's Umbrella
- Saint Nicholas: A Story of Joyful Giving
- Snoodlerella (from Sweetpea Beauty)
- Sweetpea Beauty
- It’s a Meaningful Life
- Twas the Night Before Easter
- Princess and the Popstar
- The Little Drummer Boy
- Lenny and the Lost Birthday (from Robin Good and His Not-So-Merry Men)
- Robin Good and His Not-So-Merry Men
- The Penniless Princess
- The League of Incredible Vegetables
- MacLarry and the Stinky Cheese Battle
- Merry Larry and the True Light of Christmas
- Veggies in Space: The Fennel Frontier
- Celery Night Fever
- Beauty and the Beet
Silly Songs
- The Water Buffalo Song
- The Hairbrush Song
- Oh Santa!
- His Cheeseburger
- Larry's High Silk Hat
- Sport Utility Vehicle
- Schoolhouse Polka
- Pizza Angel
- My Baby Elf
- Gated Community
- Lance the Turtle
- The Biscuit of Zazzamarandabo
- Sneeze If You Need To
- Sippy Cup
- Donuts for Benny
- Pants
- Goodnight Junior
- The Hopperena
- Astonishing Wigs
- The Eight Polish Foods of Christmas
- Bubble Rap
- Best Friends Forever
- Supper Hero
- Kilts and Stilts
- Wrapped Myself Up for Christmas
- Asteroid Cowboys
- Perfect Puppy
- Mac and Cheese
Trivia
- In The Pirates Who Don't Do Anything, some scenes had to be cut in order to make the film shorter.